Darned if you do and darned if you don’t.
That’s over seeding for you. If there is ever an unnecessary task in golf course management that is by most accounts necessary, it’s winter over seeding.
To put it in another perspective, if the love of money is indeed the root of all evil, then over seeding is a necessary evil – an agronomic procedure aimed more at wooing winter play in the southern environs of America than for any meaningful enhancement of turf health.
Over seeding is most commonly done by courses that use Bermuda grass, which goes dormant in winter, courses that over seed will prepare their Bermuda grass for over seeding through a combination of processes that include aeration, verticutting and scalping. The ryegrass seed is then distributed on top of the Bermuda grass and nurtured for several weeks as it germinates and grows in the upper profile of the Bermuda grass that is entering dormancy. In late spring as the weather warms up, the golf course superintendent will encourage the Bermuda grass as it comes out of dormancy and the ryegrass is losing its ability to withstand the warmer weather.
Many courses either close during over seeding or offer discounted greens fees during these periods because of the disruption to play that over seeding causes.
It could also be said that over seeding is one of the more visible signs of the state of modern golf and the care of its venues. As the playing and paying customers flee the northern climes beset by winter, they are truly in search of the green. Thus, superintendents across the nation’s southern tier of states avoid the brown — dormant Bermuda grass — and perpetuate the green by over seeding with a cool-season grass. To call it a cosmetic practice would be accurate, but also simplistic. The economic viability of thousands of golf courses and the job security of those who manage them loom beneath the pretty, green surface. The key fact is, golf courses that rely on winter play to be a successful operation must, for better or worse, over seed to achieve that level.
Many issues have been addressed along the way, such as impact on play, costs, water usage and chemical removal of the ryegrass in transition because of its tendency to hang on too long in the Southwest. For those superintendents and facilities that choose not to over seed , they often find their course provides variety and challenge as the seasons change. Beyond aesthetics, overseeding does provide better turf conditions in the winter. Without it, many courses have to combat wear and compaction problems caused by player and golf car traffic. However, they have their reasons for avoiding over seeding:
- Water conservation – Dormant Bermuda grass uses far less water than over seeded perennial ryegrass.
- Uninterrupted play in the fall – Courses avoid the disruption and course closure often required for over seeding.
- No spring transition problems – Without competition from over seeded ryegrass, Bermuda grass can green up earlier in the spring.
- Ease of weed control – It is easier to control annual bluegrass and weeds in dormant Bermuda grass with selective and non-selective herbicides.
- Sustain a stronger strand of warm season grasses – Many courses experience a gradual decline of Bermuda grass density after years of renovation and over seeding. Without over seeding, courses can build a strong strand of Bermuda grass throughout the fall that will provide better density and playing quality the following spring and summer.
- Lower maintenance costs – Courses that do not over seed may save $750 to $1,000 per acre by not purchasing seed. Overall costs are lower for water, fertilizer and mowing; plus there is less wear on equipment.
On the other hand, dormant Bermuda grass has produced golfer complaints based on its lack of green color; worn areas, especially in high traffic zones; and slow recovery from divot damage. Non-agronomic advantages to managing dormant Bermuda grass include the subtle changes in playing quality during the winter. Tee shots often roll farther, different clubs and types of shots are required and hazards that are usually unreachable may now come into play. All of this adds up to a course that provides variety and challenges as the seasons change.
It’s the age-old question for golf facilities, to over seed, or not to over seed? The answer, however, is not cut and dried.